How to combat the counter offer

If you are responsible for recruitment within your team or organisation you’ve no doubt experienced how competitive the current candidate market is. The number of vacancies listed in the healthcare sector is growing, yet with border restrictions and the fear of uncertainty, there are fewer candidates actively applying for roles.


Active job seekers hold the power with many being in situations where they have multiple offers on the table, from both other opportunities or their current employers in a bid to retain them. In order to ensure a successful recruitment outcome for your vacancy, you must anticipate that multiple and counteroffers are more prevalent than ever and could impact your recruitment process. 


At every touchpoint engage with your candidate, seek to understand what other roles they are considering or in the process for. This will help discover the appeal of other opportunities and understand how your offer is positioned against them. Benchmark your offer (remuneration and benefits) to ensure it meets what others in the market are offering. This doesn’t necessarily mean increasing the salary (although in some instances this will work) there are other factors equally important to job seekers in the current market. Work/life balance has fast become one of the biggest motivating factors for candidates to seek a new opportunity, evaluating your roster structure to accommodate this will help your opportunity stand out. The ability to be flexible with your offer demonstrates to a candidate that you invested in a long term partnership with them. 


In order to mitigate the risk of your preferred candidate accepting a counter offer there are steps you can take from the start to set yourself up for success. First and foremost, a clear timeline from the 1st interview through to the job offer will provide structure and keep the wheels moving.  Regularly check in with your applicants to keep them engaged - even letting them know there are no updates is an update to them. If there are multiple stakeholders involved that will be a part of your 2nd or 3rd interview book those interview times in their calendars from the outset - the scramble to align everyone’s schedules towards the end of the process adds pressure and stress that can easily be avoided by organising this in advance. Time is precious and waiting for calendars to align could mean the difference between a candidate accepting an offer that has already been presented to them instead of waiting for you. 


Ensure you and your team are ready to sell your brand and promote all the great things about working in your business. When engaging a potential new hire, share the importance of the role, the challenges they may face (for many candidates this is a positive opportunity for them to make a difference to your organisation and customers), outline the training that will be provided throughout onboarding and ongoing and lastly share examples of others in your business; when they started, how they progressed and the long-term progression pathways available within the company. Be honest and open, there should be no questions left unanswered - the more information a candidate has, the easier it is for them to make the decision to join your team. 


Checklist:

  • Your position description is up to date and ready to share
  • Process and timeline in place and all stakeholders engaged (ideally 5-10 days max)
  • Market checked your remuneration and benefits on offer
  • Does your job advertisement position the vacancy well to stand out in this market?
  • Candidate engagement plan - all aboard and ready to sell your organisation and job opportunity


Our team has experienced the surge in counteroffers firsthand, they’re more than happy to chat with you in more detail about how your business can overcome this and ensure you have a successful recruitment outcome.


By RWR Group Marketing August 17, 2026
Learn how general practitioners, practice nurses and practice managers can navigate career progression outside the NZ hospital system.
By RWR Group Marketing August 10, 2026
Discover why leadership roles outside the hospital system are rising and how to prepare for your next permanent healthcare career step in NZ.
By RWR Group Marketing August 3, 2026
Discover how a permanent talent strategy resolves hiring challenges in NZ primary care, aged care, and community health organizations.
By RWR Group Marketing July 28, 2026
Discover practical strategies to retain your best healthcare professionals.
By RWR Group Marketing July 20, 2026
Understand what NZ health employers are looking for in mid-senior hires. Practical insight for experienced health professionals.
By RWR Group Marketing July 14, 2026
Stand out in NZ health recruitment. Practical CV advice for mid to senior health professionals looking for their next permanent role.
By RWR Group Marketing July 6, 2026
Salary gets people in the door. Culture is what keeps them there. Across New Zealand's health sector, we are seeing the same pattern repeat: organisations lose their best senior people not always to better pay, but to better workplaces. The professional has found somewhere that feels right. And that feeling is built on culture. What Professionals Are Looking For After years of experience, health professionals know what they want from a workplace. They are not easily impressed by perks or job titles. What they respond to is depth: clear values, consistent leadership, psychological safety and a sense that the organisation genuinely cares about the people delivering care. In our conversations with experienced GPs, allied health clinicians, practice managers and aged care leaders, a few themes come up consistently. WHAT CULTURE MEANS TO HEALTH PROFESSIONALS Leadership that listens and follows through A team that supports each other, especially under pressure Recognition that goes beyond performance reviews Genuine flexibility, not just a policy on paper A workplace where raising concerns is safe and welcomed Culture Is Not a HR Initiative One of the most common mistakes health employers make is treating culture as something the HR team manages. In reality, culture is built and broken in everyday interactions. How a person is briefed before a difficult conversation. Whether a practice manager is consulted before a process change. How a team responds when someone admits they are stretched. Leaders at every level carry culture. And senior professionals are watching closely. What This Means for Retention When a high-performing person hands in their notice, it is rarely a sudden decision. It is the end of a longer journey that often started with a moment of disconnection. A decision made without their input. A value that was stated but not lived. A leader who did not follow through. The organisations retaining their people are the ones paying attention to these moments. They are conducting stay conversations, not just exit interviews. They are creating conditions where people feel seen before they start looking elsewhere. Start the Conversation If you lead a health organisation and you are not actively talking to your people about what they need, now is the time to start. Not just about pay. About how the work feels. About what would make them stay for another three years, not just another quarter. At RWR Health, we work with health employers across New Zealand to attract and retain permanent staff across primary care, aged care, allied health, NGO and private medical sectors. Visit www.rwrhealth.co.nz to find out how we can help, or get in touch to have a confidential conversation about your team.
By RWR Group Marketing June 10, 2026
By RWR Marketing
By RWR Group Marketing May 19, 2026
Real long-term outcomes from healthcare professionals who migrated to Australia and New Zealand. Where are they now and what would they tell you?
By RWR Group Marketing May 14, 2026
Worried AI will replace your healthcare role? Here's what's actually changing, what isn't and why the sector remains one of the most secure career paths.